Annie Elise

Elise argues Shirilla's parents hurt her cause by participating in a Netflix documentary.

“her parents did not do her any favors with doing the Netflix documentary”

Serialously with Annie Elise: 416: Incest Dad Basically Walks Free, Teen Marly Kinney Vanishes At Boat Party & Sisters Murder and Smile After (Jul 2, 2026) · Listen from 7:06

Annie Elise stated that this would be her final episode on Mackenzie Shirilla.

“Now, let me just start this episode by saying this, okay? This will be my last Mackenzie Sherilla episode”

Serialously with Annie Elise: 407: Mackenzie & Her Dad’s Creepy Texts, Plus Her Weird Jail Calls with Mom | Mackenzie Shirilla (Jun 5, 2026) · Listen from 0:43

Elise notes that GPS evidence of an alleged dry run three days before the crash was not included in the Netflix documentary.

“there was evidence found, which Netflix also did not include, in her GPS history that she did what they called a dry run”

Serialously with Annie Elise: 403: Mackenzie’s Cringey Jail Calls, TikToker & Her Dad Plan Murder, & Katie Price Missing Husband (May 28, 2026) · Listen from 24:13

Elise calls Shirilla a narcissist who feels she does not belong in prison and is above everyone else.

“I think she is a narcissist to the degree of not even that she didn't envision herself in there”

Serialously with Annie Elise: 403: Mackenzie’s Cringey Jail Calls, TikToker & Her Dad Plan Murder, & Katie Price Missing Husband (May 28, 2026) · Listen from 22:20

Elise believes Shirilla's survival was a fluke and that she claimed memory loss because she panicked after surviving.

“I think it was a fluke, and I think that when she realized she survived, that's when she panicked and said she didn't remember anything”

Serialously with Annie Elise: 403: Mackenzie’s Cringey Jail Calls, TikToker & Her Dad Plan Murder, & Katie Price Missing Husband (May 28, 2026) · Listen from 21:35

Elise corrects her earlier episode, saying a second blood sample taken by the medical flight crew was tested.

“apparently there was another blood sample that was taken from the life flight or flight life or whatever it is from the night or the morning of the crash, and that one was tested”

Serialously with Annie Elise: 403: Mackenzie’s Cringey Jail Calls, TikToker & Her Dad Plan Murder, & Katie Price Missing Husband (May 28, 2026) · Listen from 18:30

Elise notes prosecutors believe more people could be involved and the investigation remains active.

“Prosecutors also have said that they do believe that more people could be involved and that the investigation is still active and still ongoing”

Serialously with Annie Elise: 402: Group of 5 Friends Charged in Death of 16-Year-Old Teen Girl | Justice for Kayla Huff (May 25, 2026) · Listen from 39:39

Elise reports that Elena is held without bail and that the other five defendants are next due in court on June 1, 2026.

“Elena is currently being held without bail or bond, and the other five defendants will not appear in court until June 1st, 2026”

Serialously with Annie Elise: 402: Group of 5 Friends Charged in Death of 16-Year-Old Teen Girl | Justice for Kayla Huff (May 25, 2026) · Listen from 42:07

Elise believes the boyfriend helped facilitate the abduction, since he was filmed with Kayla before she was taken.

“he was the one seen on footage with her luring her to whatever the destination was that she was abducted”

Serialously with Annie Elise: 402: Group of 5 Friends Charged in Death of 16-Year-Old Teen Girl | Justice for Kayla Huff (May 25, 2026) · Listen from 42:07

Elise expresses disbelief that six people would go along with the plot out of blind loyalty when Kayla had wronged no one.

“it's this blind loyalty, but to get six people on board with that blind loyalty, especially when it's not like Kayla wronged anyone”

Serialously with Annie Elise: 402: Group of 5 Friends Charged in Death of 16-Year-Old Teen Girl | Justice for Kayla Huff (May 25, 2026) · Listen from 36:45

Elise relays Hunter Ames's account that the suspects said they had someone in the trunk of a Chevy Impala and needed his pistol.

“They told him that they had someone in the trunk of a white Chevy Impala and they needed his pistol to, quote, take care of it”

Serialously with Annie Elise: 402: Group of 5 Friends Charged in Death of 16-Year-Old Teen Girl | Justice for Kayla Huff (May 25, 2026) · Listen from 25:59

Elise reports the affidavit's allegation that suspects poured motor oil into Kayla's fuel tank the day before she vanished to disable her car.

“intentionally took motor oil from the bed of an acquaintance's truck and then poured that motor oil into the fuel tank of Kayla's car”

Serialously with Annie Elise: 402: Group of 5 Friends Charged in Death of 16-Year-Old Teen Girl | Justice for Kayla Huff (May 25, 2026) · Listen from 26:06

Elise worries the retrial may not allow financial crimes evidence as extensively, opening room for reasonable doubt.

“I don't believe that they're allowed to bring in the financial crimes as much as they did in the last trial”

Serialously with Annie Elise: 416: Incest Dad Basically Walks Free, Teen Marly Kinney Vanishes At Boat Party & Sisters Murder and Smile After (Jul 2, 2026) · Listen from 2:23

Elise predicts Alex Murdaugh will again be found guilty at his retrial, though she has some reservations.

“I'm confident that he will still be found guilty. However, I want to put that big however in there”

Serialously with Annie Elise: 416: Incest Dad Basically Walks Free, Teen Marly Kinney Vanishes At Boat Party & Sisters Murder and Smile After (Jul 2, 2026) · Listen from 3:23

Elise said she had heard that evidence of Murdaugh's financial crimes may be limited or excluded at the retrial.

“I don't think, from what I'm hearing, they're allowed to bring the financial crimes in as much or at all into this new trial”

Serialously with Annie Elise: 401: Disney Cruise Busted, Missing Scientist & Makayla Settles’ Dad Pleads Guilty (May 21, 2026) · Listen from 23:11

Elise predicted that Murdaugh would still be convicted at the new trial.

“I think that it's going to be still a slam dunk conviction on the new trial”

Serialously with Annie Elise: 401: Disney Cruise Busted, Missing Scientist & Makayla Settles’ Dad Pleads Guilty (May 21, 2026) · Listen from 22:41

Elise argues that killing a co-parent over custody makes no sense because it would leave the child without a parent.

“just get a divorce and move on because now you're pissed over custody so much so that you're gonna off your the co-parent”

Serialously with Annie Elise: 403: Mackenzie’s Cringey Jail Calls, TikToker & Her Dad Plan Murder, & Katie Price Missing Husband (May 28, 2026) · Listen from 43:13

Elise expects Gonzalez's ex-boyfriend Kai to turn on Gonzalez and her father.

“I would imagine the now scorned ex-boyfriend is going to flip on both of them”

Serialously with Annie Elise: 403: Mackenzie’s Cringey Jail Calls, TikToker & Her Dad Plan Murder, & Katie Price Missing Husband (May 28, 2026) · Listen from 41:50

Elise explains that the plot failed because the hitman the group tried to hire on the dark web was an undercover officer.

“The person that they thought they were hiring on the dark web as this hitman, like we have seen in so many cases, was actually an undercover cop”

Serialously with Annie Elise: 403: Mackenzie’s Cringey Jail Calls, TikToker & Her Dad Plan Murder, & Katie Price Missing Husband (May 28, 2026) · Listen from 39:30

Elise says she read, without being sure of its accuracy, that Jonathan made a business decision that cost Mango about $160 million.

“made a business decision that cost the company like I want to say $160 million or something like that”

Serialously with Annie Elise: 403: Mackenzie’s Cringey Jail Calls, TikToker & Her Dad Plan Murder, & Katie Price Missing Husband (May 28, 2026) · Listen from 34:03

Elise says the Andic family's public support for Jonathan does not sway her, since wealthy families protect their legacy.

“if it's this successful, huge family, they don't want their legacy being tarnished. They are going to stand by him”

Serialously with Annie Elise: 403: Mackenzie’s Cringey Jail Calls, TikToker & Her Dad Plan Murder, & Katie Price Missing Husband (May 28, 2026) · Listen from 35:59

Elise argues that Jonathan Andic's repeated visits to the site suggest he was scouting a location to push his father.

“to do a walkthrough three different times the week before, you're obviously scouting locations for where you're going to, in my opinion, push him”

Serialously with Annie Elise: 403: Mackenzie’s Cringey Jail Calls, TikToker & Her Dad Plan Murder, & Katie Price Missing Husband (May 28, 2026) · Listen from 35:44

Elise says Netflix documentaries are usually made by third-party producers, so Netflix may not know what was left out.

“It's not Netflix who outright produces these and like puts the storyboard together. It's usually third parties who then sell it to Netflix”

Serialously with Annie Elise: 403: Mackenzie’s Cringey Jail Calls, TikToker & Her Dad Plan Murder, & Katie Price Missing Husband (May 28, 2026) · Listen from 5:11

Elise said Shirilla's ER blood sample from the morning of the crash was ordered discarded and never tested.

“the physician ordered that it be thrown away. So it was never tested”

Serialously with Annie Elise: 401: Disney Cruise Busted, Missing Scientist & Makayla Settles’ Dad Pleads Guilty (May 21, 2026) · Listen from 52:43

Elise argued that Netflix omitted damaging details about Shirilla because it had secured interviews with her and her parents.

“It's because they were able to secure an interview with her parents and with Mackenzie”

Serialously with Annie Elise: 401: Disney Cruise Busted, Missing Scientist & Makayla Settles’ Dad Pleads Guilty (May 21, 2026) · Listen from 49:45

Elise speculated that the story's low visibility in search results might reflect a coordinated effort by Disney to bury it.

“so i don't know if that's some like coordinated effort because from from disney who's working with like google adwords”

Serialously with Annie Elise: 401: Disney Cruise Busted, Missing Scientist & Makayla Settles’ Dad Pleads Guilty (May 21, 2026) · Listen from 39:26

Elise cautioned that there was no public evidence of a trafficking ring connected to Disney cruises.

“there is no public evidence currently that this was any sort of trafficking ring, that it's, you know, a trafficking ring connected to Disney cruises”

Serialously with Annie Elise: 401: Disney Cruise Busted, Missing Scientist & Makayla Settles’ Dad Pleads Guilty (May 21, 2026) · Listen from 33:24

Elise noted that none of the 28 detained cruise workers had been publicly charged; instead they were deported.

“None of the 28 workers have publicly been criminally charged in the United States. at least not that we know of right now”

Serialously with Annie Elise: 401: Disney Cruise Busted, Missing Scientist & Makayla Settles’ Dad Pleads Guilty (May 21, 2026) · Listen from 31:03

Elise recommends that people who notice a loved one in an apparent mental health crisis call for help rather than wait it out.

“maybe rather than trying to just wait it out or rationalize with them, maybe you do call in for help”

Serialously with Annie Elise: 417: Grey’s Anatomy Inspired Murder: He Walked Inside, Then Took a Knife from the Kitchen | Logan Tipton (Jul 6, 2026) · Listen from 52:17

Elise reports that the psychiatric team concluded Exantus showed signs of psychosis for over a week before the killing and was not faking.

“investigators ultimately came to the conclusion that Ronald had been showing signs of psychosis for well over a week before Logan's murder”

Serialously with Annie Elise: 417: Grey’s Anatomy Inspired Murder: He Walked Inside, Then Took a Knife from the Kitchen | Logan Tipton (Jul 6, 2026) · Listen from 36:34

Elise argues it seems contradictory that Exantus was found legally insane for the murder but guilty of assaults in the same incident.

“how do you say that someone was legally insane when they committed the murder, but not insane when they assaulted the others in that same incident?”

Serialously with Annie Elise: 417: Grey’s Anatomy Inspired Murder: He Walked Inside, Then Took a Knife from the Kitchen | Logan Tipton (Jul 6, 2026) · Listen from 41:01

Elise explains that the prosecution argued Exantus's behavior resulted from synthetic drugs, while the defense cited a blood test showing only an inactive marijuana component.

“They claimed Ronald wasn't suffering from mental illness at all, that his behavior, it was all the result of synthetic drugs that can cause psychosis”

Serialously with Annie Elise: 417: Grey’s Anatomy Inspired Murder: He Walked Inside, Then Took a Knife from the Kitchen | Logan Tipton (Jul 6, 2026) · Listen from 37:47

Elise speculated that the warm milk texts might have been code for marijuana or something else.

“I do think that it's possible that it was code for something else, maybe blunt, maybe something else”

Serialously with Annie Elise: 407: Mackenzie & Her Dad’s Creepy Texts, Plus Her Weird Jail Calls with Mom | Mackenzie Shirilla (Jun 5, 2026) · Listen from 2:13:47

Elise said she did not believe the warm milk texts were code for a sexual relationship between Mackenzie and her father.

“I don't believe, and I could totally be wrong, I don't believe that this was code for them sleeping together”

Serialously with Annie Elise: 407: Mackenzie & Her Dad’s Creepy Texts, Plus Her Weird Jail Calls with Mom | Mackenzie Shirilla (Jun 5, 2026) · Listen from 2:13:47

Elise said she believed Natalie Shirilla wanted to be her daughter's friend rather than her parent.

“She's one of the parents, I believe wholeheartedly, who wants to be Mackenzie's friend more than Mackenzie's parent”

Serialously with Annie Elise: 407: Mackenzie & Her Dad’s Creepy Texts, Plus Her Weird Jail Calls with Mom | Mackenzie Shirilla (Jun 5, 2026) · Listen from 2:13:04

Elise argued that Shirilla's parents enabled her excessively.

“Which I think we all can agree that her parents just enable her to like the ends of the earth”

Serialously with Annie Elise: 407: Mackenzie & Her Dad’s Creepy Texts, Plus Her Weird Jail Calls with Mom | Mackenzie Shirilla (Jun 5, 2026) · Listen from 2:25

Elise argues that repeated commenters claiming to be Kayla's relatives lend some legitimacy to the rumored motive, while acknowledging they could be fake.

“I saw it in enough places that it gives, in my opinion, a little bit of, you know, legitimacy to the speculation”

Serialously with Annie Elise: 402: Group of 5 Friends Charged in Death of 16-Year-Old Teen Girl | Justice for Kayla Huff (May 25, 2026) · Listen from 29:42

Elise shares an unverified social media claim that Chris and Elena killed Kayla because she caught them having sex, stressing it is speculation.

“So Chris and Elena killed Kayla Huff because they got caught having sex with each other”

Serialously with Annie Elise: 402: Group of 5 Friends Charged in Death of 16-Year-Old Teen Girl | Justice for Kayla Huff (May 25, 2026) · Listen from 33:18

Elise noted that Casias leaving her medication behind conflicts with the theory of a planned departure.

“you're always going to need medication if you have an illness”

Serialously with Annie Elise: 401: Disney Cruise Busted, Missing Scientist & Makayla Settles’ Dad Pleads Guilty (May 21, 2026) · Listen from 48:59

Elise said she believed Casias planned her disappearance, possibly because someone was threatening her.

“She absolutely intentionally planned to leave, for whatever reason that is, to start a new life because somebody was threatening her”

Serialously with Annie Elise: 401: Disney Cruise Busted, Missing Scientist & Makayla Settles’ Dad Pleads Guilty (May 21, 2026) · Listen from 48:26

Elise said that California prison overcrowding and good-behavior credits could mean Settles' father serves only a year or so.

“he could be out in as little as a year or a year and a half, which is so appalling”

Serialously with Annie Elise: 401: Disney Cruise Busted, Missing Scientist & Makayla Settles’ Dad Pleads Guilty (May 21, 2026) · Listen from 4:56

Elise reported that, because the father maintains the encounter was consensual and no assault charges were brought, he faces at most three years at sentencing.

“the maximum sentence that he will face when he is sentenced, which is scheduled for June 23rd, get this, will be three years”

Serialously with Annie Elise: 401: Disney Cruise Busted, Missing Scientist & Makayla Settles’ Dad Pleads Guilty (May 21, 2026) · Listen from 4:56

Elise describes Logan's Law as requiring anyone found not guilty by reason of insanity to remain in a secure mental institution for life.

“A law that would require anyone found not guilty by reason of insanity to remain in a secure mental institution for the rest of their lives”

Serialously with Annie Elise: 417: Grey’s Anatomy Inspired Murder: He Walked Inside, Then Took a Knife from the Kitchen | Logan Tipton (Jul 6, 2026) · Listen from 52:32