Nancy Guthrie disappearance
Event in True Crime
Nancy Guthrie disappearance has come up in 1 episode across 1 podcast in TMT, including The Megyn Kelly Show. 3 people have made recorded remarks about it.
What people said
James HamiltonFormer FBI supervisory special agent who created the FBI's close protection school; security consultant
Hamilton criticizes the FBI's decision to pull resources back to Phoenix and says a county sheriff cannot run the case alone.
“Ni allwch chi wneud hynny'n unig fel Sieriff Cymru”
The Megyn Kelly Show: CNN Identity Crisis, and How Boys Become Men, with Jesse Kelly, and New Nancy Guthrie Timeline Questions, with James Hamilton and Maureen O'Connell | Ep. 1283 (Mar 27, 2026) · Listen from 2:14:04
Hamilton says he would have expected Annie to lead with the blood on the porch rather than the propped door, suggesting the family did not know about it.
“Ni fyddwn i'n arwain â drws wedi cael ei ofyn. Byddwn i'n arwain gyda blwyd”
The Megyn Kelly Show: CNN Identity Crisis, and How Boys Become Men, with Jesse Kelly, and New Nancy Guthrie Timeline Questions, with James Hamilton and Maureen O'Connell | Ep. 1283 (Mar 27, 2026) · Listen from 1:56:30
Hamilton says scammers routinely invoke God and religious language to manipulate victims' families, and that such phrasing is a red flag.
“Bydd y sgamwyr yn gwneud unrhyw beth ac yn dweud unrhyw beth”
The Megyn Kelly Show: CNN Identity Crisis, and How Boys Become Men, with Jesse Kelly, and New Nancy Guthrie Timeline Questions, with James Hamilton and Maureen O'Connell | Ep. 1283 (Mar 27, 2026) · Listen from 1:49:29
Hamilton says the reported note details are too generic and that he would need non-public specifics before treating the notes as genuine.
“Byddwn i'n dweud bod llai o bersonalwch yma y byddwn i'n hoffi ei weld”
The Megyn Kelly Show: CNN Identity Crisis, and How Boys Become Men, with Jesse Kelly, and New Nancy Guthrie Timeline Questions, with James Hamilton and Maureen O'Connell | Ep. 1283 (Mar 27, 2026) · Listen from 1:38:26
Maureen O'Connell25-year FBI veteran and co-host of the 'Best Case Worst Case' podcast
O'Connell says she believes Savannah Guthrie knows her mother is dead but hopes to bring her home for a celebration of life.
“I actually believe that savannah knows her mom's gone i i don't see any hope left for her to be alive”
The Megyn Kelly Show: CNN Identity Crisis, and How Boys Become Men, with Jesse Kelly, and New Nancy Guthrie Timeline Questions, with James Hamilton and Maureen O'Connell | Ep. 1283 (Mar 27, 2026) · Listen from 2:27:43
O'Connell says the Apple Watch detail and its location are the elements that likely convinced the FBI the first note was credible.
“So it's got a couple of elements that just no one else knew about unless they were there”
The Megyn Kelly Show: CNN Identity Crisis, and How Boys Become Men, with Jesse Kelly, and New Nancy Guthrie Timeline Questions, with James Hamilton and Maureen O'Connell | Ep. 1283 (Mar 27, 2026) · Listen from 2:00:39
O'Connell says the FBI's standard guidance is not to pay a ransom without proof of life.
“Wel, dwi'n meddwl bod y FBI yn ei ddweud, heb arwain o bywyd, nad ydych chi'n gwneud cymorth i'r bobl hyn”
The Megyn Kelly Show: CNN Identity Crisis, and How Boys Become Men, with Jesse Kelly, and New Nancy Guthrie Timeline Questions, with James Hamilton and Maureen O'Connell | Ep. 1283 (Mar 27, 2026) · Listen from 1:36:21
Megyn KellyConservative broadcaster and podcaster
Kelly criticizes the Today show interview for failing to ask Savannah why the family did not pay after saying they would.
“This was the biggest interview in the country this week. And she completely fell down on the job. Why didn't you pay then?”
The Megyn Kelly Show: CNN Identity Crisis, and How Boys Become Men, with Jesse Kelly, and New Nancy Guthrie Timeline Questions, with James Hamilton and Maureen O'Connell | Ep. 1283 (Mar 27, 2026) · Listen from 2:25:00
Kelly finds it strange that Annie Guthrie apparently waited about an hour or more before calling Savannah after discovering their mother missing.
“bod Annie Guthrie ddim wedi alw Savannah Guthrie am awr, yn ymddangos, ar ôl ei gwybod bod rhywbeth wedi mynd yn iawn iawn â'i mam”
The Megyn Kelly Show: CNN Identity Crisis, and How Boys Become Men, with Jesse Kelly, and New Nancy Guthrie Timeline Questions, with James Hamilton and Maureen O'Connell | Ep. 1283 (Mar 27, 2026) · Listen from 1:52:56
Podcasts
- The Megyn Kelly Show · 1 episode
Episodes
CNN Identity Crisis, and How Boys Become Men, with Jesse Kelly, and New Nancy Guthrie Timeline Questions, with James Hamilton and Maureen O'Connell | Ep. 1283The Megyn Kelly Show · Mar 27, 2026 · 2 h 31 min
Megyn Kelly, Jesse Kelly, James Hamilton and Maureen O'Connell discuss the Iran war's political fallout, CNN's identity crisis, raising boys, and the Nancy Guthrie case.