CNN Identity Crisis, and How Boys Become Men, with Jesse Kelly, and New Nancy Guthrie Timeline Questions, with James Hamilton and Maureen O'Connell | Ep. 1283
Episode of The Megyn Kelly Show · March 27, 2026 · 2 h 31 min
Megyn Kelly, Jesse Kelly, James Hamilton and Maureen O'Connell discuss the Iran war's political fallout, CNN's identity crisis, raising boys, and the Nancy Guthrie case.
Summary
Megyn Kelly opened with Axios reporting that Vice President JD Vance had confronted Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu over pre-war predictions that regime change in Iran would come easily, and with an incident in which the Israeli government press office muted NBC's Richard Engel during a Netanyahu press conference. Kelly argued that those who persuaded President Trump to join the war — naming Netanyahu, Lindsey Graham, Mark Thiessen, General Jack Keane, Mark Levin and Ben Shapiro — should be held accountable.
Jesse Kelly argued that allies in war rarely share identical end goals and that Israel and the United States had diverged. He said Trump's political survival depended on economic conditions rather than foreign policy, citing polls showing Trump deeply underwater on Iran, and warned that a ground deployment of 5,000 to 17,000 troops could hand Democrats decades of power. Both hosts discussed collapsing approval numbers among independents, Hispanics and young Republicans, rising oil prices, Iran's control of the Strait of Hormuz, and the difficulty of finding an off-ramp.
The conversation then turned to legacy media. Kelly and Jesse Kelly mocked CNN's shifting attempts at authenticity — low-tech maps, piped-in control-room audio, unbuttoned shirtsleeves — and argued that cable outlets conditioned audiences who will not tolerate ideological deviation, which they said doomed Bari Weiss's tenure at CBS News. A clip of CBS anchor Tony Dokoupil crying on air prompted a discussion of masculinity, with Jesse Kelly arguing that boys build confidence only through adversity and praising UConn coach Dan Hurley's tough approach.
In the final segment, former FBI agents James Hamilton and Maureen O'Connell examined a report from the X account Nerdy Addict that the second note in the Nancy Guthrie case contained an apology and said she had "gone to be with the Lord." Both expressed skepticism, noting the details cited were publicly available and that scammers routinely invoke God, and both questioned the roughly three-hour gap before Annie Guthrie called Savannah, the absence of the district attorney from the case, and the family's decision not to pay a ransom without proof of life.
Chapters
- 0:59
Vance confronts Netanyahu
Kelly reviews Axios reporting on a tense exchange between JD Vance and Benjamin Netanyahu over failed predictions about regime change in Iran.
- 6:18
Israel mutes Richard Engel
Kelly plays audio of NBC's Richard Engel having his microphone cut at a Netanyahu press conference and criticizes Israeli press controls.
- 13:23
Jesse Kelly on divergent war aims
Jesse Kelly argues allies rarely share identical end goals and that Trump must find an off-ramp for political survival.
- 17:44
Polling collapse and the economy
The hosts review Harry Enten's polling data, Fox News numbers on Hispanics, and argue economic anxiety drives voters more than foreign policy.
- 22:11
Ground troops and 2026 stakes
Kelly and Jesse Kelly discuss reports of up to 17,000 U.S. troops, Strait of Hormuz oil disruption, and the risk of Democratic sweeps.
- 30:50
War hawks and Fox News dissent
Kelly criticizes Ben Shapiro and Mark Levin's rhetoric and plays Will Cain's skeptical exchange with General Jack Keane.
- 51:55
CNN's identity crisis
The hosts mock CNN's low-tech and high-tech authenticity experiments and argue cable audiences reject deviation from established ideology.
- 1:01:50
Bari Weiss and CBS News ratings
Kelly argues Weiss lacks broadcast experience and that CBS Evening News is heading for record-low ratings.
- 1:08:20
Tony Dokoupil's tears and masculinity
A clip of the CBS anchor crying prompts Jesse Kelly's argument that men should not perform emotion on television.
- 1:13:23
How boys become men
Jesse Kelly and Megyn Kelly discuss Dan Hurley's coaching, adversity, raincoats in Sweden, and Michael Caine's 'how can this be useful' ethos.
- 1:28:43
The second Guthrie ransom note
Kelly introduces Nerdy Addict's report that the second note was an apology saying Nancy had gone to be with the Lord.
- 1:38:26
Hamilton and O'Connell analyze the notes
The former FBI agents weigh whether the notes are genuine, noting the Apple Watch detail and scammers' use of religious language.
- 1:49:56
Timeline questions and the missing DA
The panel questions the gap before Annie called Savannah, the propped door, the polygraphs, and the absence of prosecutors from the case.
- 2:21:22
Why the family didn't pay
Kelly presses on why the Guthries said they would pay but did not, and the guests discuss proof-of-life protocols and remaining hope.
Key points
What was said, by whom, with the exact words. Timestamps jump to the moment.
Linked moment · 2:56Skip to 2:56 using a listen link in the info box.
Megyn KellyKelly argues that the people who persuaded Trump to join the Iran war should be publicly identified and held to account.
“As this thing goes south, we need to know exactly who talked him into it and what representations were made to convince the President that this was a good idea”
- Megyn Kelly
Kelly characterizes Israel's muting of Richard Engel at a press conference as Soviet-style press manipulation.
“This is like, this is Pravda-esque type shit”
Listen from 11:11 · Freedom of the press in the United States
- Jesse Kelly
Jesse Kelly says Trump's coalition was built on non-hardcore MAGA voters who are furious about the economy and feel he is insufficiently focused domestically.
“Mae 66% o'r Amerigwyr yn credu nad yw'n canolbwyntio'n ddigon i'r cyffrediniaeth Trump”
- Jesse Kelly
Jesse Kelly argues that allies in war share goals only up to a point, after which their desired endings diverge.
“Rydyn ni'n gydweithio gyda Israel yn y ffaith nad ydym ni'n hoffi Iran”
- Jesse Kelly
Jesse Kelly argues it is always easy to start a war but very difficult to find an off-ramp once events spiral beyond control.
“Mae'n bob amser wedi bod yn hawdd dechrau war”
- Megyn Kelly
Kelly says Iran is now earning far more from oil because it controls the Strait of Hormuz, which was open before the U.S. bombing campaign began.
“Mae Iran yn gwneud arian oherwydd maen nhw wedi cymryd drosodd Hormuz”
- Megyn Kelly
Kelly cites Reuters polling that only 7% of Americans would support sending 5,000 to 17,000 ground troops to Iran.
“7% o'r Pobl Arican fydd yn cefnogi hynny”
- Jesse Kelly
Jesse Kelly frames the Iran war as a choice about whether it is worth handing every branch of government back to Democrats.
“Mae'r arweinyddiaeth ddynol, Donald Trump, yn rhaid iddyn nhw benderfynu a yw'r war yma yn Iran yn berthnasol i'r comiwnistiaid sy'n cyflawni pob rhan o'r llywodraeth eto yng Nghymru”
- Jesse Kelly
Jesse Kelly argues that people preoccupied with personal financial hardship will not care about Iran, Ukraine or nuclear weapons; they want jobs.
“Maen nhw ddim yn gofyn am unrhyw beth. Maen nhw eisiau swydd, period”
- Megyn KellyPartly true
Kelly predicts the full energy-price pain from the war will hit over the summer, shortly before the midterm elections.
“We're only feeling the initial tremors that the full pain will come just in time for summer vacations”
- Megyn Kelly
Kelly says Will Cain is the only Fox News host willing to ask skeptical questions about the war.
“I love Will Cain, and he's an honest broker. But he's the only one who's like”
- Jesse Kelly
Jesse Kelly argues legacy anchors lost their audience because viewers now have unlimited alternatives and only authenticity works.
“Yr unig beth y gallwch chi ei wneud nawr yw eich bod chi”
- Jesse Kelly
Jesse Kelly argues CBS conditioned its audience so thoroughly toward left-wing content that any move to the middle drives those viewers away.
“If you're straying an inch from that, the viewers you used to have, they're going to leave and they'll go find different commie propaganda”
- Megyn Kelly
Kelly predicts Bari Weiss's CBS News experiment will fail because she lacks broadcast experience and internal support.
“She doesn't have the support of the troops inside. She's not going to. This is not an experiment that's going to work out”
- Jesse Kelly
Jesse Kelly argues that men crying on television is now normalized but that men should show strength rather than emotional display.
“Yr unig bobl sydd eisiau gweld y sgwrs hwnnw yw dynion unigol sydd wedi cael eu llwyddo ar Xanax”
- Jesse Kelly
Jesse Kelly argues that confidence can only be earned through enduring hard experiences, not through praise or reading.
“Nid ydych chi'n gallu caru eich ffordd i mewn i hynny neu dweud wrthyn nhw eich bod chi'n gyffredinol eich ffordd i mewn i hynny”
- Jesse Kelly
Jesse Kelly says he deliberately arranged menial summer jobs for his son so he learns to endure bad bosses and poor pay.
“for crappy pay and it's going to be outstanding for him because one day he's going to have a job at 25 26 that may not be ideal”
- Maureen O'Connell
O'Connell says the FBI's standard guidance is not to pay a ransom without proof of life.
“Wel, dwi'n meddwl bod y FBI yn ei ddweud, heb arwain o bywyd, nad ydych chi'n gwneud cymorth i'r bobl hyn”
- James Hamilton
Hamilton says the reported note details are too generic and that he would need non-public specifics before treating the notes as genuine.
“Byddwn i'n dweud bod llai o bersonalwch yma y byddwn i'n hoffi ei weld”
- James Hamilton
Hamilton says scammers routinely invoke God and religious language to manipulate victims' families, and that such phrasing is a red flag.
“Bydd y sgamwyr yn gwneud unrhyw beth ac yn dweud unrhyw beth”
- Megyn Kelly
Kelly finds it strange that Annie Guthrie apparently waited about an hour or more before calling Savannah after discovering their mother missing.
“bod Annie Guthrie ddim wedi alw Savannah Guthrie am awr, yn ymddangos, ar ôl ei gwybod bod rhywbeth wedi mynd yn iawn iawn â'i mam”
- James Hamilton
Hamilton says he would have expected Annie to lead with the blood on the porch rather than the propped door, suggesting the family did not know about it.
“Ni fyddwn i'n arwain â drws wedi cael ei ofyn. Byddwn i'n arwain gyda blwyd”
- Maureen O'Connell
O'Connell says the Apple Watch detail and its location are the elements that likely convinced the FBI the first note was credible.
“So it's got a couple of elements that just no one else knew about unless they were there”
- James Hamilton
Hamilton criticizes the FBI's decision to pull resources back to Phoenix and says a county sheriff cannot run the case alone.
“Ni allwch chi wneud hynny'n unig fel Sieriff Cymru”
- Megyn Kelly
Kelly criticizes the Today show interview for failing to ask Savannah why the family did not pay after saying they would.
“This was the biggest interview in the country this week. And she completely fell down on the job. Why didn't you pay then?”
- Maureen O'Connell
O'Connell says she believes Savannah Guthrie knows her mother is dead but hopes to bring her home for a celebration of life.
“I actually believe that savannah knows her mom's gone i i don't see any hope left for her to be alive”
People
In the conversation
- Megyn KellyConservative broadcaster and podcaster
- Jesse KellyAmerican conservative talk radio host of 'The Jesse Kelly Show' and 'I'm Right', and Marine Corps veteran
- James HamiltonFormer FBI supervisory special agent who created the FBI's close protection school; security consultant
- Maureen O'Connell25-year FBI veteran and co-host of the 'Best Case Worst Case' podcast
Discussed
- JD VanceVice President of the United States
- Benjamin NetanyahuPrime Minister of Israel
- Donald TrumpPresident of the United States whose conduct of the Iran war is the episode's main subject
- Richard EngelNBC correspondent cited for persisting when his microphone was cut during a Netanyahu event
- Lindsey GrahamU.S. Senator named by Kelly as an advocate for the Iran war
- Mark LevinConservative radio host who pressed for strikes on Iran
- Ben ShapiroConservative commentator who advocated the Iran war
- Jack KeaneRetired U.S. Army general and Fox News analyst
- Miriam AdelsonIsrael-first megadonor said to own an Israeli newspaper that ran a hit piece on Vance
- Harry EntenCNN data reporter cited for polling on the Iran war
- Bari WeissEditor-in-chief of CBS News, criticized by Wagner over ratings
- Tony DokoupilCBS Evening News anchor criticized for crying on air
- Dan HurleyUConn men's basketball coach praised for tough coaching
- Andrea HurleyWife of Dan Hurley
- Michael CaineBritish actor cited for the ethos of asking how a setback can be useful
- Savannah GuthrieNBC Today co-anchor and daughter of Nancy Guthrie
- Nancy Guthrie84-year-old mother of Savannah Guthrie who disappeared on January 31
- Annie GuthrieSavannah Guthrie's sister who discovered their mother missing
- Harvey LevinTMZ founder who received and described the first ransom note
- Chris NanosPima County Sheriff leading the Guthrie investigation
- Carson DalyNBC personality whose family Savannah spent the day with
- Hoda KotbFormer Today show host who interviewed Savannah Guthrie
- Anderson CooperCNN anchor cited by Lemon as an iconic journalist
- Jake TapperCNN anchor whose program is being reformatted in a podcast style
- Roger AilesLate Fox News founder credited with understanding televised visual medium
- Joe RoganAmerican comedian and host of The Joe Rogan Experience
- Robert F. Kennedy Jr.Health secretary whose appointment Jesse Kelly cited as coalition-building
- Matt MurphyFormer prosecutor quoted asking where the district attorney is in the Guthrie case
- Brian EntinReporter who covered polygraph testing in the Guthrie case
Topics
- United States war with Iran
- Nancy Guthrie disappearance
- CNN
- CBS News
- Donald Trump approval rating
- 2026 United States midterm elections
- Strait of Hormuz
- Crisis of boys and young men
- Fox News
- Gas prices and inflation
- Federal Bureau of Investigation
- Freedom of the press in the United States
- Polygraph testing
- Vietnam War
- Rhodesian Bush War
Related episodes
Have Republicans Already Blown the Midterms?Pod Save America · Oct 18, 2026 · 1 h 11 min
Dan Pfeiffer and Cook Political Report's Amy Walter assess the 2026 midterm landscape two weeks out, covering Senate and House races, polling, Trump, and redistricting.
#346 James Lechner - Army Ranger Recounts the Battle of Mogadishu: Black Hawk DownThe Shawn Ryan Show · Oct 8, 2026 · 3 h 20 min
Retired Army Ranger James Lechner tells Shawn Ryan about fighting and being wounded in the 1993 Battle of Mogadishu, turning around Ramadi, Afghanistan policy failures, and the war in Ukraine.
JRE MMA Show #186 with Sean SharafThe Joe Rogan Experience · Oct 1, 2026 · 2 h 21 min
Joe Rogan talks with UFC heavyweight Sean Sharaf about his 12-second upset knockout of Gable Steveson, possible retirement, MMA rules, Gaza, surveillance, and AI.
Impeach Pete Hegseth?Pod Save America · Sep 29, 2026 · 58 min
Jon Favreau, Tommy Vietor and Jon Lovett discuss diesel prices, a Republican data center bill, rogue AI models, a possible Pete Hegseth impeachment and Trump's taxpayer-funded ads.
“This Will Be The Most Violent Election Of Our Lifetime” - Robert Pape #1154Modern Wisdom · Sep 24, 2026 · 1 h 43 min
Political scientist Robert Pape tells Chris Williamson that mass public support for political violence makes the coming US midterms the most dangerous election in living memory.
#2555 - Ron WhiteThe Joe Rogan Experience · Sep 16, 2026 · 2 h 34 min
Joe Rogan and comedian Ron White discuss Kill Tony, cigars, cars, fitness, Texas politics, cannabis laws, the Iran war, Jelly Roll's Kimmel monologue, and religion.
More from The Megyn Kelly Show
How the Media Shapes the Cornell Lie, with Matt Taibbi, and the Harms of "White Guilt," with Eli and Shelby Steele | Ep. 1414Oct 8, 2026 · 1 h 43 min
Megyn Kelly discusses media coverage of the Cornell fraternity sexual assault case with Matt Taibbi, then talks with Shelby and Eli Steele about their documentary White Guilt.
- Joe Biden's Incoherent Book Launch, Meghan Markle's Emmy Nom, and Ellen's TRUE Persona, with Adam Carolla | Ep. 1360
Jul 15, 2026 · 1 h 42 min
Megyn Kelly and Adam Carolla discuss Democratic political theatrics, the Butler shooting, Joe Biden's book promo, Meghan Markle's Emmy nod, celebrity personas, and the JPMorgan lawsuit.
- Horrifying Case of Left-Wing Terrorism, and Prince Harry's FAILED UK Trip, with Alex Phillips and Rob Shuter | Ep. 1359
Jul 14, 2026 · 1 h 42 min
Megyn Kelly discusses Ann Widdecombe's murder and UK political violence with Alex Phillips, then Prince Harry's lawsuit loss, royals, Taylor Swift's wedding and Blake Lively with Rob Shuter.
- Lindsey Graham's Legacy, McConnell's "Proof of Life," and the Robinson Video You DIDN'T See, with Knowles, Posobiec, and Fitz | Ep. 1358
Jul 13, 2026 · 1 h 42 min
Megyn Kelly discusses Lindsey Graham's death, McConnell's health and Elliot Page with Michael Knowles, then the Tyler Robinson hearing with Jack Posobiec and James Fitzgerald.
- Judge Graf Shows ZERO Confidence Despite MOUNTAINS of Evidence in Tyler Robinson Hearing, Lance Twiggs DOWNPLAYS His "Trans" Identity, w/ Aronberg, Frei, Eiglarsh, Murphy & Spilbor | Ep. 1357
Jul 10, 2026 · 1 h 44 min
Megyn Kelly and legal analysts Dave Aronberg, Viva Frei, Matt Murphy, Mark Eiglarsh and Jonna Spilbor dissect day five of Tyler Robinson's preliminary hearing.
From the publisher
Megyn Kelly begins the show by reacting to new reporting on tensions between VP JD Vance and Benjamin Netanyahu over Israel's failed predictions about the Iran war, Israel censoring American media, and more. Then Jesse Kelly, host of "I'm Right" and "The Jesse Kelly Show," joins to discuss the long-term political consequences of a potential U.S. ground invasion in Iran, the risk of economic fallout and how it could ultimately lead to decades of Democrat rule, what recent polling reveals about declining support for the Iran war, why Americans are not emotionally invested in this war, the cheerleaders on the right pushing for continued escalation, CNN’s ratings struggles and weird attempts to be more authentic, corporate media's identity crisis as audiences shift to on-demand media, why young men need to face adversity to build real confidence, the dangers of a more feminized and overly softened culture, how tough coaching and discipline can shape strong leaders, and more. Then James Hamilton, former FBI and security expert, and Maureen O’Connell, host of "Best Case Worst Case," to discuss shocking new reporting that a second note in the Nancy Guthrie case may have been an apology rather than a ransom demand, why authorities may have advised against paying without proof of life, new questions about the timeline of Nancy Guthrie’s disappearance, what Savannah Guthrie’s comments about when she first learned her mom was missing reveal about the family dynamic, and more. Kelly - https://jessekelly.com/ Hamilton- https://www.hamiltonsecuritygroup.com/ O'Connell- https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/best-case-worst-case/id1240002929 Joi + Blokes: Go to http://joiandblokes.com/MK and use code MK for 65% off your labs and 20% off all supplements Relief Factor: Find out if Relief Factor can help you live pain-free—try the 3-Week QuickStart for just $19.95 at https://ReliefFactor.com or call 800-4-RELIEF. Brooklyn Bedding: Upgrade your sleep with Brooklyn Bedding—Visit https:…
Summary, chapters and key points were generated from the episode transcript on September 27, 2026. Quotes are checked word for word against the transcript.